Chapter one
Tile, stone slate and a Grade I church
A church roofed in tile with a stone-slated tower shows how differently two old coverings age, and why each needs its own repair.
A church was already standing at Cocking by 1086, and the present building is listed Grade I. The Victoria County History describes flint walls with ashlar dressings, mostly Henley sandstone, and a tower of local malm rock, plastered. Its roofs are tile, apart from the tower, which wears stone slates. For anyone looking after an old roof in the village, that pairing is a useful lesson. Tiles and stone slates are laid differently, wear differently and fail differently, so a survey has to treat them as two separate problems, even when they sit on the same building and share the same gutters.
At a glance
- A church stood here by 1086
- Church roofs are tile; the tower is stone slate
- Cocking Church is listed Grade I
1.1 Where a tiled roof meets a flint wall
Flint walls are rough, so a lead flashing, the metal strip dressed over the join between roof and wall, has to follow every bump and hollow. Along each wall we see whether the lead still sits in a raked mortar joint, not simply stuck on with sealant, and whether any gap lets rain run in behind it. Water that enters at a wall junction often appears as a damp patch well away from the real fault, so we follow the water upstream before we quote anything. Our photographs of the junction are attached to the written quote, and you can look at the problem on your own building.
1.2 Stone slates are a different trade
Stone slates are thick, heavy and normally laid in diminishing courses, with the biggest at the eaves. When one splits, the answer is rarely a like-for-like replacement from a merchant's shelf. Reuse comes first in the Stone Roofing Association's Horsham guidance: put back as many of the roof's own slates as can be saved. The same logic suits any old stone roof. We take the slates off, grade them by size and lay the sound ones again, keeping the graded piles together so that new work matches old. Where the roof is a tower, access and weight are part of the plan from the first visit.
1.3 Church or house, the consent differs
Where a parish church is still in use for worship, the Church of England's faculty system governs works to it, under the ecclesiastical exemption, and not the council. A listed house is different. The South Downs National Park Authority draws the line between upkeep and change: routine care and small in-situ repairs need no listed building consent, but work that replaces historic fabric outright or alters the building's character does. Before we plan work on a listed Cocking roof, we ask which of those two situations applies.
What people sayA Grade I listing means no roof repair can be done without listed building consent.
What is trueRoutine upkeep and small repairs in matching materials need no consent; replacing historic fabric or altering the building's character does.






